Book Review: Jerusalem Maiden by Talia Carner

30 May

Genre: Historical fiction

Publisher: HarperCollins (Harper Paperbacks)

Pub date: 31 May 2011

Source: Publisher via NetGalley


Esther Kaminsky is a young girl in an ultra-Orthodox Jewish family in Jerusalem. Set at the decline of the Ottoman Empire, Jerusalem Maiden tells the story of Esther’s lifelong struggle between her God and her passion.


This is a great story, very well-written with so many details of the daily lives of the people. Carner has made the story more than about a religion or even religion – it has a universality. When we are brought up being told something is right and the only way, it takes a lot of courage and introspection to go a different way. It’s hard to decide what is right and good and what can lead to destruction. And religious faith has a hold like nothing else – the fear and guilt that comes from breaking the rules have very dire consequences.

For those who don’t know much about this time and the Orthodox Jews, (like me) this story is an eye-opener.

Esther knows that according to her religion, her duty is to get married and produce many sons to hasten the Messiah’s arrival. But when her French teacher discovers that Esther has brilliant artistic talent, she comes to a fork in the road. Her love for art is so strong that Esther only wants to paint and draw. But she is torn: between her faith which says it is a sin to create graven images and her drive to paint and draw.

She is a rebel in her own way – she quietly questions the tenets by which her family and the community lives. Women do all the hard labour while the men pursue religious studies. She is an intelligent girl, capable of having academic discussions, but as a girl about to become a woman, she is required to focus on learning to run a home. As Esther grows up, this rebellious streak gets her into trouble. In any Orthodox society it is very hard for a young girl to maintain her reputation. Esther goes from being beloved daughter that her father is so proud of to a troublesome unmarried girl and a burden. But through it all, Esther’s faith in God stays strong.

When tragedy strikes the family, Esther sees it as a warning from God. She locks up her desire to paint and devotes herself to becoming an obedient Jerusalem maiden. But long-suppressed desires rise to the surface and she once again has to make a decision: is it her destiny to follow her passion? Why would God give her his talent and if He did not mean for her to pursue it? Esther tries to interpret her religion for herself. Her belief and courage takes her a long way from home and a long way from her beliefs.

Jerusalem Maiden is clearly Esther’s story, but it is peopled with some very memorable characters. I loved going with Esther on this journey. If there is one drawback to the book, it is that this struggle does feel a little repetitive. But I grew to care so much about Esther that throughout I was rooting for her to find peace.


Highly recommended. Even those who have no strong feelings about god/faith or religion will be pulled into Esther’s story.

Rating: 4.75*

*See my Rating policy

Did you enjoy this post? You can subscribe to posts from Stargazerpuj’s Book Blog by mail or RSS to get updates.


4 Responses to “Book Review: Jerusalem Maiden by Talia Carner”

  1. Talia Carner August 1, 2011 at 11:57 pm #

    Thank you so much for your great review of JERUSALEM MAIDEN!

    I would also like to share with your followers the exciting book group promotions we have initiated: Groups that select JERUSALEM MAIDEN can participate in the drawings of unique gifts.

    1) A collectors’ edition bottle of JERUSALEM MAIDEN wine grown in the Jerusalem mountains–and carrying the label of the book’s cover art!
    2) A Holy Land religious package of three vials: Galilee anointment oil, holy water from the Jordan River, and stones from Jerusalem —for each attendee,
    3) An autographed copy of JERUSALEM MAIDEN.

    Please e-mail a photograph of your group holding their copies of the novel (Kindle screen is OK, too.)

    And of course, if my schedule permits, I’d be delighted to participate in the meeting over the phone. Please write to me via my website at .

    Either way, because of the social issues behind my writing, I always promise my readers a lively and thought-provoking discussion at the meeting.


    Talia Carner

  2. Audra (Unabridged Chick) August 18, 2011 at 9:55 pm #

    I so enjoyed this novel — it was so bittersweet! I could have cried at the end — gah! I loved the unusual setting and thought Esther was such a marvelous heroine.


  1. Historical Fiction Challenge 2011 Wrap-up « Stargazerpuj's Book Blog - December 27, 2011

    […] Jerusalem Maiden by Talia Carner […]

  2. 2011: Bookish Snapshots « Stargazerpuj's Book Blog - December 30, 2011

    […] by Anuradha Roy A Passage to India by E.M. Forster Tiny Sunbirds, Far Away by Christie Watson Jerusalem Maiden by Talia Carner The Folded Earth by Anuradha Roy Miss Timmins’ School for Girls by Nayana […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: